Truelovestories
Go
Punished for My Twin Sister's Mistake—Until Mom Mixed Us Up AGAIN and I Switched Our SATs
Chapter 1



My twin sister and I are identical. Even Mom and Dad can't tell us apart.

At 7, Brielle stole ten bucks. Mom beat the shit out of ME.

At 12, I ranked #1. Dad promised me Disney.

I waited. And waited. What I got? The three of them coming back from Disney. Without me.

"Sorry, Ashlyn. We mixed you up again."

"Next time, okay? Be good."

EIGHTEEN YEARS of that.

All I could do was nod, fighting back tears.

Until the night before the SAT. I overheard them in the study.

"Don't worry, Bri. I'll drop Ashlyn at your test center. She takes the SAT for you."

"You're not missing out on college."

That's when it hit me—they COULD tell us apart.

They just chose to screw me over. Every. Single. Time.

Fine.

Their SAT-switching game? I'm in.

...

The next morning, I walked out of my room.

Mom was passing by with a glass of milk. The second she saw my face, she screamed.

"Ashlyn! What happened to your face?!"

Brielle came running out of her room.

The instant she saw the scar on my face, all the color drained from hers.

"Cut myself peeling an apple last night," I said calmly, as if it wasn't my face we were talking about.

Mom grabbed my arm and tried to drag me toward the door.

"We're going to the hospital! Right now!"

"You can't have a scar. Absolutely CAN'T."

I yanked my arm back.

"The SAT's next week. I don't have time for this."

"It's just a scratch. I'm not dying."

No matter how hard Mom begged, I grabbed my bag and walked out.

The second I stepped into class, the room went dead silent.

Everyone crowded around me, staring at the scar on my right cheek.

"Holy shit, Ashlyn—what happened to your face?"

"Well, at least now we can finally tell you and Brielle apart."

"Yeah, you guys used to look like clones. Now there's a mark."

I quietly nodded and opened my notes.

Mr. Harrison noticed too. He waved me over.

"Ashlyn. Hallway. Now."

Out in the hall, he sighed and tapped his roster.

"The SAT has strict facial recognition requirements."

"Now that you have a scar, your old ID photo won't match anymore."

"You need to retake it with the scar, or you won't even get into the test center. Understand?"

I nodded obediently.

"Got it, Mr. Harrison."

That night at dinner, the air was suffocating.

Dad sat there smoking in silence.

Mom was even more distracted. Her hands were shaking as she tried to serve food.

Then, out of nowhere, Brielle slammed her fork down and snapped.

"Mom! You KNOW I hate cilantro. Why do you keep putting it in my plate?!"

Mom stared at the pile of cilantro in Brielle's plate, finally snapping out of her daze.

She immediately began apologizing.

Dinner ended fast.

Late that night, I stood outside the study.

Mom's sobs drifted through the door.

"Ashlyn has a scar on her face now!"

"How is she supposed to take the SAT for Brielle?"

"Michael, say something!"

"If Brielle doesn't get into a good college, her life is over!"

The room went dead quiet. Just the click of a lighter.

Then, after what felt like forever, Dad spoke firmly.

"If Ashlyn's face is scarred up, facial recognition won't work on her."

"Then we make Brielle cut her own too."

Mom's sobbing stopped abruptly.

Minutes later, from the shadows of the hallway, I watched Mom walk into Brielle's room.

With a knife.

Chapter 2



The next day, Brielle had a fresh scar on her right cheek.

Same spot, same length, even same angle—identical to mine.

She stormed toward the dining table, her expression dark and murderous.

I looked at her, all fake surprise.

"What happened, Bri. You're clumsy too?"

She grabbed the bowl in front of her and smashed it on the floor.

CRASH!

Scalding soup splattered everywhere.

She jabbed her finger at my face, exploding with rage.

"Shut the hell up, Ashlyn Harper!"

Mom rushed over and pulled her into a comforting hug, eyes red.

"It's okay, sweetheart. Don't be upset."

"I promise—after the SAT, we'll take you to the best plastic surgeon. No scar. I swear."

It took Mom forever to calm Brielle down.

Finally, she followed me out the door.

Brielle was already pissed off by the heat. The second we walked into class, she ripped off her mask.

The room went dead silent.

Everyone's eyes darted between the two of us, their faces full of disbelief.

"Wait—Brielle got a scar too?"

"What the hell? The scars are in the exact same spot. Do twins have some kind of psychic link or something?"

Annoyed by the whispers around her, Brielle yanked her mask back on and slammed her head down on her desk.

I sat down and calmly opened my notes.

After homeroom, Mr. Harrison called us both into his office.

He stared at the bandages on our faces.

"Alright. Tell me the truth. What's going on here?"

"Yesterday Ashlyn cuts her face. Today Brielle cuts hers in the exact same spot?"

Brielle avoided his eyes, stubbornly sticking to her story.

"Mr. Harrison, it really was an accident."

"I woke up half asleep and bumped into something sharp."

Mr. Harrison frowned, then turned to me.

I nodded along, face totally sincere.

"Brielle really did hurt herself by accident, sir."

"Mine too, obviously."

"Twin thing. You know how it is."

He stared at us for a long time before letting out a heavy sigh.

Then he pulled two forms out of his drawer and handed them to us.

"These are applications for facial photo modification."

"Go retake the photo at lunch—make sure the injury shows—and fill out the form."

"Bring them back to me before you submit. Got it?"

At lunch, I went with Brielle to get the photos taken.

We printed them, pasted them on the forms, filled everything out.

By the time we were done, class was about to start.

Out in the hallway, Brielle shoved her form at me like I owed her.

"Turn mine in too. I'm going back to sleep—this is so damn annoying."

I looked down at the two applications in my hands.

And nodded sweetly.

"Sure thing."

Chapter 3



I turned and headed to Mr. Harrison's office.

Right before I pushed the door open, I pulled out my own application, folded it in half and shoved it into my hoodie pocket.

Only Brielle's form stayed in my hand.

I knocked and walked in. Set the form flat on his desk.

Mr. Harrison glanced at it. His face darkened immediately.

"Only Brielle Harper’s application? Where's yours?"

I met his gaze, a faint smile tugging at my lips.

"Mr. Harrison, I'm not updating mine."

"Don't be ridiculous!"

His voice went sharp.

"This isn't a game. If your face doesn't match the system, you won't even get into the test center."

I stayed calm. Pointed at the bandage on my cheek.

"Don't worry, sir. It's just a surface scratch. Barely anything."

"The doctor said it'll heal completely in a few days. No scar. It'll definitely be gone before the SAT."

He studied me for several seconds.

He knew me—I was always a responsible and careful student. Always had my shit together.

Finally, his frown softened.

"Fine. But don't screw around with your future."

"Thank you, sir."

Once I was out of his office, I pulled my form from my pocket and casually tossed it in the trash by the stairwell.

From that day on, Brielle completely checked out.

She slept through morning study hall. Wore earbuds during math. Turned in blank homework.

Eventually, she started skipping class altogether.

Said her face hurt. Spent her days at the café scrolling TikTok.

I walked over to her desk one day, all fake concern.

"Bri, the SAT's coming up. You should at least try to study a little, even with the scar."

"If you slack off now, your score's gonna tank."

Brielle rolled her eyes.

"Mind your own business. Quit bugging me."

I shut up and went back to my seat.

A few days later, Brielle stopped coming to school entirely.

She took a leave of absence, claiming she needed to "recover at home."

Really just binge-watching shows in her air-conditioned room.

Watching Mom and Dad indulge her like that, I put my fork down and put on my cold face—deliberately.

"Mom. Dad. I can't focus at school anymore. The pressure's too much."

"If Brielle gets to stay home, I'm not going tomorrow either."

The room went dead silent.

Dad's expression darkened almost instantly.

"Absolutely not."

"The SAT's in a week. You think you can afford to slack off?"

"How are you supposed to do well if you're not studying?"

Mom immediately joined in, her voice sharp with accusation.

"Ashlyn, stay out of this."

"You're going back to school, and you're finishing every single practice test—not one less."

I looked at their panicked faces.

And almost laughed.

"Fine."

I lowered my head, hiding the cold amusement in my eyes.

The days peeled off the calendar one by one.

Until finally, SAT day arrived.

👉 Click to read more exciting content